Comparison · Insurance

AgencyZoom vs Shape

AgencyZoom and Shape side by side for insurance: scores by criterion, native features, and pricing.

Updated September 30, 2026

Higher scoreInsurance software

AgencyZoom

6.4

Fairout of 10

Sales CRM built for insurance producers — pipelines, AMS integration, renewal automation, and two-way texting. The vendor’s own FAQ says it does not replace the AMS. Independent plans publish Essential $149, Growth $199, and Pro $349 per month for up to seven seats.

From $149/mo (independent Essential, up to 7 users); Allstate from $99/mo; 14-day trial

Read full profile Official site

Insurance software

Shape

5.0

Weakout of 10

All-in-one sales CRM with an insurance industry page — pipelines, native calling and two-way SMS, automation, mobile app. Core/Complete/Enterprise are quote-based. Not an AMS: no policy downloads, commission recon, or comparative rater in the product under review.

Contact for pricing

Read full profile Official site

Criteria where AgencyZoom wins

Ties

Criteria where Shape wins

Score by criterion

In green, who wins the criterion. The overall score uses insurance weights: policies and book of business and commissions and carrier money weigh more.

CriterionAgencyZoomShape

Policies and book of business1.4×
Policy records — number, coverage, carrier, and status — without a parallel spreadsheet or a second system of record.
4.2
3.5
Commissions and carrier money1.2×
Commission tracking, splits, or carrier-statement reconciliation in the same product as the policy — not a sibling SKU or a spreadsheet.
4.0
2.8
Renewals and retention1.1×
Renewal workflow, alerts, and retention on the in-force book — not only a “won” stage or a new-business funnel.
8.2
5.0
Native messaging0.9×
Native SMS or messaging inbox on the client or policy card, with team history. WhatsApp Business API also counts. Portal-only chat and marketplace apps do not.
8.0
8.8
Price and transparency0.8×
Public plan in USD, trial, and what sits outside the monthly fee. Mandatory add-ons for day-to-day AMS work lower the score.
8.0
4.2
Learning curve0.8×
English UI, policy and commission vocabulary, and time until a producer or CSR can work without a months-long implementation project.
8.2
7.4
Overall score
6.4
5.0

Native features

Only what is part of the product counts. Marketplace integrations or third-party apps are out.

FeatureAgencyZoomShape

Policy book of businessNoNo
Commissions & carrier moneyNoNo
Renewals & retentionYesNo
Multi-carrier quotingNoNo
Insurance complianceNoNo
Native messagingYesYes
Sales pipelineYesYes
Vendor mobile appYesYes

Compare with another rival

Each pair has its own page. The ranking only highlights the main duels — the rest are here and on each CRM profile.

Compare AgencyZoom with

Compare Shape with